Skip to Content

Reasons You Should Never Buy the Disney Dining Plan

Reasons You Should Never Buy the Disney Dining Plan

The value of the Disney Dining Plan has been long argued by guests. There seem to be two camps the people who absolutely love it and use it every trip and those who are adamant they will never buy the Disney Dining Plan. Today I am going to break down why people say the dining plan is a waste of money and that they don’t use it. This can help you decide whether or not you want to get the dining plan on your next Disney World vacation.

Strip Steak at Yachtsmen Steakhouse.

Too Much Food

The first response I have is the dining plan is wow, way too much food. Disney food is delicious don’t get me wrong but a big sit down meal every night and then immediately follow it up with a dessert, you really have to stuff it in. When we tried out the dining plan I am not going to lie, I struggled and most often didn’t finish my food. Both lunch and dinner include a dessert.

Have I mentioned that a big meal slows down your ability to hustle onto as many rides as possible after dinner? Those big meals can make walking back to the bus after dinner a struggle!

Dinner isn’t the only time you are overfed, you get a lot of food at lunch too. Just think if you stop in at Flame Tree Barbeque to have lunch and you order the Chicken and Ribs, that comes with baked beans, coleslaw, and a dessert. The portions are huge at Disney and this meal could easily be split between two and both would feel plenty full by the end of it.

Makes Signature Dining Overpriced

Do you like the finer things in life? If your idea of a good vacation includes the likes of enjoying a meal at Yachtsmen Steakhouse and California Grill than the dining plan isn’t the way to go for you. While Disney does allow you to eat at these locations it’s going to cost you two credits. Two table service credits equal out to almost $80/per person. Even at these more expensive spots, it’s nearly impossible to make up the cost of using two credits.

One the second page of this link you can see all the Disney restaurants that require two credits.

Miss Out on Park Time

When you are eating at a sit-down restaurant you are missing out on precious park time. Sometimes it’s really nice to get a break and rest your feet so you can close down the park. On average a sit-down meal can take about two hours. You should expect at a minimum an hour but most take longer.

You Still Need to Bring the Money

While many rave about the convenience the Disney Dining Plan offers, you will need to still bring money with you. The tip for your server is not included and you will have to pay 18%-20% gratuity in person. Keep in mind had you not opted for the dining plan you may have gone to less sit-down meals. This would mean avoiding having to pay a tip or for such an expensive meal every night of your stay.

Water is Not Included

If your family are not big soda drinkers then the $8/day of drinks Disney charges are going to be lost. Both lunch and dinner include your choice of a soda, tea, or coffee. If this is something you normally would skip you should take that into consideration.

Kids are Charged as Adults

In Disney’s eye when you are 10 you are an adult, and let’s be honest the reality is that just isn’t the case. I know every child is different but I am guessing a lot of you parents out there reading this don’t want to be paying for an adult meal for your 10-year-old or even 12 years old. Not to mention if your kid isn’t a big eater you are going to waste a ton of food and money.

Everything Becomes About Food

If you are not a foodie you probably don’t want your whole trip to turn into where you are eating and when. Dining reservations can be booked up to 180 days out. Which means you should probably already have your park days planned so you know where to book. The downfall then becomes you may be going to a park just because that’s where you could get a reservation, not that it’s necessarily where you wanted to be.

You Don’t Save Money

I saved my biggest reason for last, the facts just come down to that most don’t save any money when using the dining plan. People have to make out spreadsheets of where they eat at places. This then breaks out the most expensive dishes and as long as everyone in your party orders that (most likely steak) you will save money. That’s just not how a vacation should be, whatever you want off the menu should be what you get. Worrying about getting your money’s worth and being restricted to select menu items is no way to go.

The advantage of the dining plan is budgeting the cost of food – use Disney’s cost per day in your budget to plan on what you will spend and then balance out the choices you make over your vacation. If you take the time to do the math, I’m sure that you will spend less just paying for you food as you go.


What do you think of the Disney Dining Plan? Share your experiences in the comments below! If you do think the Disney Dining Plan is the right fit for your family here is some information on how to make sure you get the most value you can out of it! Also, check out the Snacks that will Maximize the Value of the Disney Dining Plan.

Why I never buy the disney dining plan

Lori

Saturday 3rd of August 2019

I disagree—We will always use the dining plan! More variety and we get to experience dining at places we wouldn’t normally go to because of the expense. And any leftover credits we end up with (not many) we use at the resort to stock up on snacks for our trip home.

Joanna

Friday 30th of November 2018

We chose the quick service plan instead of the dining plan. The quick serve plan was great for our family. It wasn't sit down, so you didn't need reservations. Since we were only eating two full meals a day, they had the perfect portion sizes for adults and teenagers. Plus, we had two snacks a day. We got free water at all the parks, so we could use the snack for food. There was no tip involved. After totaling how much we would have spent, we made out better with the pla.

Jan Fasone

Sunday 9th of September 2018

We usually go when the free dining is available. That usually saves us about $700-$800. Neither one of us are big eaters and the portions seem to be enough.

Amanda

Wednesday 31st of January 2018

We go when the dining plan is free. It saves us a lot of money and we eat better than we would otherwise. My 12 year old daughter is 5’8” and 118 pounds and can out eat me any day. The last time we went she was 9 and the kids meals did not fill her up. We shared our adult meals with her.

Sarah

Wednesday 24th of January 2018

We went last year with our toddler and did the middle Dining Plan (1 quick, 1 sit down and 2 snack per day). I mainly did it for the character meals, you never know how a Tiny Tot is going to react to characters, so I figured this would be a good way to test the waters and get a break from the park. Well, she loved the chsracters! She looked forward to our sit down meals to see the characters in person without having to wait in line. We used 1 snack per day for our venti Starbucks in the morning. Those 2 things just about paid for the Dining Plan each day and made it cost effective for us. We're there some meal choices we made that weren't worth it? Sure. But, overall, for our family it worked. When we go back next year, we will probably do it again for the character meals.

Need More Help Planning Your Vacation?

A travel agent is an essential resource when planning a vacation. Reach out to Magical Travel and they will make sure your vacation is pure magic and no stress! Their services are 100% FREE to you!