Skip to Content

Mama Melrose Dining Review

Mama Melrose Dining Review

Mama Melrose is tucked away in the very back of Hollywood Studios I feel as though this is the often missed out on dining opportunity of the park. I have found that the food here is really hit or miss. You can either have a fantastic meal or a meh meal and this last trip I think I figured out the key to success. So the secret is you don’t order traditional Italian dishes and you will love your meal here. Let’s now take a look at our full Mama Melrose dining review.

Mama Melrose Quick Breakdown

  • Service: Table-Service
  • Type of Food: Italian, Vegetarian-Friendly, Allergy Options
  • Price: $$
  • Location: Hollywood Studios
  • Disney Dining Plan: Yes, 1 Credit
  • Discounts: Annual Passholder, Tables in Wonderland
  • Features: Reservations, Alcohol
  • Good For: Casual Dining
  • Menu: Official Disney Dinner Menu

A Tour Around Mama Melrose’s

Outside of Mama Melrose

As soon as you walk in you will be greeted with the check-in podium that is pictured below. The restrooms are here as well as some fresh water which was perfect considering how hot it was on this fall day!

Mama Melrose Dining Review 17

Mama Melrose has a nice quaint feel and is covered with all sorts of little knickknacks. The story goes that Mama came west from Italy to make her name in Hollywood. While the actress fame didn’t pan out, she opened her “Ristorante Italiano” and gained a place in the heart of her new city that way!

Mama Melrose Dining Review 18

Don’t forget to look at the walls. Just look at this very inspired pizza art they hung on the walls!

Mama Melrose Dining Review 19

Here is a wider look at the seating area in Mama Melrose. The outer walls have booths which is what we were seated at.

Mama Melrose’s Dishes

The following is a few of the dishes we have tried from their menu.

Appetizers from Mama Melrose

Bread and Oil to start off your meal at Mama Melrose.

Bread and Oil to start off your meal at Mama Melrose.

Pretty much your standard rolls with an awesome seasoned oil. The taste is along the lines of what you would find at Bonefish Grill or Carrabbas.

Vegetarian Minestrone

Vegetarian Minestrone

This soup was a great starter and a perfect complement to any of the menu options.

Fresh Mozzarella and Vine-ripened Tomatoes

I was impressed with how fresh the Mozzarella and Vine-ripened Tomatoes were! The dish is topped with Balsamic Drizzle, Olive Oil, and Sweet Basil Leaves.

Carne d'Italia Flatbread

This is the Carne d’Italia Flatbread. It’s one of the more pricier appetizer options and is honestly big enough to be a meal! It’s a fantastic value if you are on the Disney Dining Plan but it makes it so hard to eat the rest of your meal.

Caesar Salad appetizer Mama Melrose

Of course, you can’t find an Italian restaurant without a Ceasar Salad on the menu This was a great pick and a very generous portion for an appetizer.

Entrees at Mama Melrose

Oven-baked Chicken alla Parmigiana

Oven-baked Chicken alla Parmigiana

This is the item I liked the least out of what we ordered. It just tasted like Prego sauce out of the jar, way too sweet and something fake tasting with the seasoning. I ate it but I didn’t enjoy it, I can pick up way better chicken parmigiana at the Carrabas right outside of Disney off of 192.

Chef's Selection Pork Shank

Chef’s Selection Pork Shank

I was pretty sure I was going to hate trying this dish but surprisingly I loved it. The pork melted in my mouth and was packed with flavor. Not sure what was in those mashed potatoes but they were so good!

Charred Strip Steak: Four-Cheese Macaroni with Pancetta, Aged Balsamic-Shallot Butter, and a Chianti Wine Reduction

Charred Strip Steak: Four-Cheese Macaroni with Pancetta, Aged Balsamic-Shallot Butter, and a Chianti Wine Reduction

The MAC AND CHEESE yummm! The steak was full of flavor and nice and tender, cooked perfectly on this trip. I feel like this dish sums up comfort food perfectly. Personally, I feel like this is the dish to get when you come here.

Desserts at Mama Melrose

Mama Melrose Dining Review 20

The Tiramisú is comprised of layers of Mascarpone and Espresso soaked Lady Fingers topped with Cocoa Powder and Whipped Cream.

Mama Melrose Dining Review 21

This is a look at the traditional Disney World kids ice cream sundae. Complete with those adorable Mickey Mouse sprinkles.

Mama Melrose Dining Review 22

The cheesecake was delicious and no sugar added!

Mama Melrose Dining Review 23

I really loved the Traditional Cannoli pictured above.

Mama Melrose Recommendation

To summarize, next trip I would go with the steak here! After having their sauces I recommend steering clear of the pasta dishes on the menu, I think it will disappoint.

If you are interested in booking a reservation for Mama Melrose you can do so through My Disney Experience. We find reservations are rather easy to make here last-minute so you don’t have to rush when booking this restaurant.

Want more dining tips? Check out our Best Disney World Restaurants recommendations along with Worst Disney Dining Sit Down Restaurants. If you are visiting with young ones read our Best Places to Eat with Kids at Disney World.

Debbie Riesner

Saturday 11th of August 2018

Just returned from Disney. Did Mama Melrose fantastic dining package for dinner for a party of 17. We have done this before and we’re very pleased. Good Food and great service. This time was very disappointing. They have restructured the dining package. It no longer includes an appetizer and the dessert is scaled down to a sample platter. It is way over priced for what is now included. The portions which used to be very generous are much smaller in size. Members of our party actually left hungry. Will not be doing it again. Spoke with a manager who admitted the information on the Internet is deceiving but it has been changed. There were several other parties who were there at the same time who also were disappointed.

Peggy Price

Thursday 15th of March 2018

I guess it also depends on what time of the year you go there. When we went in late August, it was totally disgusting. The flies! OMG, the flies! We spent half the time at the table shooing away flies from our food. Disgusting for a restaurant that's not an outdoor quick service restaurant. We have never eaten there since. I agree about the Italian food not being great. We didn't try the steak since it was an Italian restaurant. The spaghetti was meh. I've had better and made better. I think it's a Disney thing because the spaghetti at Tony's in the Magic Kingdom wasn't any better.

Patty Staricha

Thursday 15th of March 2018

OMG EWE!!! Flies in a restaurant is not good, we luckily did not run into that issue. Totally agree on the spaghetti, Via Napoli is the only Italian at Disney World I actually enjoy!

Need More Help Planning Your Vacation?

A travel agent is an essential resource when planning a vacation. Reach out to Magical Travel and they will make sure your vacation is pure magic and no stress! Their services are 100% FREE to you!